The Secret to Staying Consistent? It’s Not Discipline

In partnership with:

THE SHIFT

In 1998, Ron Chernow embarked on a monumental task: to write a biography of John D. Rockefeller Sr., a figure often vilified as a ruthless monopolist. At the time, few had attempted a comprehensive, balanced portrayal of Rockefeller, and many had failed to capture the complexities of his character. Chernow, however, saw in Rockefeller a man whose life story was rich with ambition, innovation, and philanthropy—a narrative waiting to be told.

Chernow’s approach was anything but casual. Instead of rushing through the project, he immersed himself fully in the subject, dedicating years to research and writing. Over the next five years, he meticulously combed through more than 22,000 pages of Rockefeller’s writings, including letters, essays, and public records. He traveled to key locations tied to Rockefeller’s life and unearthed a 1,700-page transcript of private interviews with Rockefeller that had never been used in any prior biography.

When Titan: The Life of John D. Rockefeller, Sr. was published in 1998, it was met with critical acclaim. The book was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award for Biography and was hailed by The New York Times Book Review as “a triumph of the art of biography.”

Reading Chernow’s story, my first thought was how disciplined he must have been—day after day at the desk, year after year. After all, most of his major works take anywhere from four to ten years to complete. But the more I sat with it, the less it seemed like raw willpower could sustain someone that long. Discipline alone burns out. Something else had to be at work.

But this is where most of us get stuck. We tell ourselves we fail because we lack discipline.

But perhaps the problem isn’t you, it’s the frame.

The Weight of Discipline

We imagine the “ideal self” as someone with military precision: alarm set at 5 a.m., meals prepped to perfection, inbox cleared before breakfast. Grinding. Producing. Staying up late to finish everything.

Discipline has the flavor of punishment baked in. Its Latin root, disciplina, means instruction, training, and correction. Discipline implies external control: a master correcting a pupil, a soldier drilled into compliance.

That’s why discipline so often feels like drudgery. It’s something you force onto yourself. When you say, “I need more discipline with my eating,” you set up an adversarial relationship with yourself: the punisher and the punished.

The Pull of Devotion

Now consider a new frame: devotion.

“Devotion” comes from the Latin devotio: to vow, to dedicate, to consecrate something as sacred. To devote yourself is to offer yourself in love and loyalty to a cause greater than convenience.

Habits born of devotion don’t need constant policing. They pull you forward instead of chaining you down.

You don’t drag yourself to the gym because “you must.” You go because you are devoted to vitality, to a body that carries you freely through life.

You don’t white-knuckle your way through meditation because “you should.” You sit in stillness because you are devoted to clarity, to being fully awake in your brief existence.

You don’t avoid junk food out of guilt. You nourish yourself out of devotion to health, to a disease-free, chemical-free body.

Devotion transforms grind into offering.

Why It Works

James Clear, in Atomic Habits, writes that true change comes not from goals, but from becoming the kind of person who embodies those goals. Psychologists might call this an identity shift.

Self-Determination Theory, one of psychology’s most robust frameworks, shows that lasting motivation arises when our actions align with our values. Discipline says: Do it because you must. Devotion says: Do it because it’s who you are.

Reframing discipline as devotion doesn’t mean abandoning effort. It means re-anchoring effort in love rather than fear, in meaning rather than shame.

Some might view Chernow’s relentless daily writing schedule as uncompromising discipline. But most of us would burn out after five years of daily writing with no finished book. Chernow approached each day not as a soldier under orders, but as a craftsman dedicated to his trade.

So maybe you don’t need more discipline. Maybe you don’t need another productivity hack, another morning routine, another “10 rules of self-mastery.”

Maybe what you need is devotion.

To vow yourself—not grimly, but lovingly—to the body you want to live in, the mind you want to cultivate, the life you want to offer back to the world.

THE ESSENTIALS

Your Weekly Toolkit